Wednesday, November 16, 2016

Backlash against Experts and Media

Whatever we might think about current events in the United States, most of us could probably agree a backlash against traditional authority and expertise has ripped through the place. A fair share probably agree this discontent and distrust extends to experts in general, for instance, in the media, the economy, the educational system, and the sciences.

So I feel the need to get something off my chest.

It’s no secret, I have a complicated relationship with experts and the media. To put it mildly. I’ve spent years of my life, my entire career really, immersed in expertise and research one way or another. Although I'm not a journalist, I've been a parenting columnist, a writer, and a blogger so I guess I'm part of the media. Yet I have spent the past decade or so debunking experts and news about kids, questioning the claims, the reporting, studies, evidence and even the expertise of some supposed experts. I’ve urged parents to do the same. I’ve urged you to do the same. To think critically, carefully, about news and advice, including the sources reporting it and the evidence behind it.

Now on first glance, this approach might sound like I’m suggesting all experts and media are worthless and should be fired. Ignored. Tossed in a new circle of hell roiling with pundits, publishers, and mommy bloggers posting the same useless or flawed advice over and over again. And researchers so in love with their own beliefs they keep finding the same thing over and over. On some days, out of sheer frustration I might have been tempted to suggest this course of action. Also, I admit, there have been times I might have used too much snark and had too much fun.

But I want to make something absolutely clear - I still believe in experts and the media even if they are imperfect.  


I NEED them. I need the news media to evolve in this new digital economy, and do a better job at cutting through the swath of information and misinformation in this post-fact era when even the facts seem up for grabs. Yes we all need the writers and news organizations trained and devoted to discovering and communicating reliable, credible, nuanced, accurate and unbiased knowledge, including scientific knowledge. Of course we also need the researchers, pediatricians and other professionals working with children steeped in experience and expertise. We will need to rely on them in this highly fractured, everybody and anybody can play an expert or can-dig-up-or-do-a-study world - with more news, more experts, more outlets, more platforms, more claims, more spin, more opinion, more evidence, more studies, more sophisticated science than ever...as traditional newsrooms (how quaint that even sounds), the Washington Posts, New York Times, etc. continue to shrink and more people turn to social media for their news and hopefully someday Facebook and Google stop promoting unreliable news and outright fake news. It is only a matter of time before FB starts hiring all the unemployed editors and reporters to start producing their own news. (Then will they care about the accuracy of news and information?) 

We need to talk about the experts more. And the media. And not just when it comes to politicians and elections. This is my hope for the coming year. 

Friday, September 23, 2016

Do Parents Matter? Doesn't matter, either way, they're messing up!

Get ready, here’s another new parenting book – and another round of Do Parents Matter? Mom, dad, you know how the drill usually goes. The latest parenting expert tells how parents do too much, too little, both, not in the right way or otherwise mess up the health and well being of their children. Parents smother, micro-manage and coddle their emotionally-stunted, over-indulged, outspoken progeny. In the global version, American parents learn how mums and dads around the world do it better. 

The Book

DO PARENTS MATTER? Why Japanese Babies Sleep Well, Mexican Siblings Don’t Fight, and American Parents Should Just Relax
By Robert A. LeVine and Sarah LeVine

The Headlines

How Much Do Parents Matter? The Atlantic

Sorry, Mom and Dad: You’re Not So Important After All NEW YORK TIMES 

Mom and Dad: Chill Out WallStreet Journal

Why Americans May Have a Lot to Learn about Parenting NPR

And yet none got it quite right. A parent could be pretty confused after reading those headlines alone. Relax, chill out, you don't matter but you have a lot to learn anyhow? I’m not sure the actual book title is spot on either, but then again I haven’t read the durn book yet. Anyone? 

The Message

In an interview at The Atlantic, when Robert LeVine was asked about the parenting advice industry, he said it “freaks” parents out.* I understand the sentiment. After traveling and observing families across the world, LeVine and his wife, both anthropologists, wrote the book to help reassure parents, to let them know they only matter to a point: 

We hope that by emphasizing the resilience of kids and demonstrating it, however anecdotally, in different cultures, we can get American parents to see that resilience is a powerful force in child development, and that kids might well turn out alright even if you don’t micromanage every aspect of their development.

Great. I appreciate the global perspective and the message that children are resilient. But then there’s that pesky “micromanage.” Is that a charge? I hope it’s just a misunderstanding due to the brevity of media content. 

The Sub-Text: American parents micro-manage too much.

I read a sub-text here (intended or not) that parents here in the United States are micromanaging too much. I didn’t read the book. I will eventually. It might not be fair to tag this discussion onto these authors, but it’s high time I get it out there. My apologies to the authors if they did cover the following in the book. Even if they don't critique parents for hovering too much, the archetypal helicopter parent is very much alive in the public and expert imagination right now. 

Whenever I see references to over-involved, hyper, helicopter or hovering parents this is what I’d like to read from the experts or authors weighing in on the matter:

We assume the sheer amount of collected news, studies and advice might have the unintended effect of making parents feel like they must micro-manage their children in all realms or put them at risk for any number of unpleasant outcomes.

Whether parents do micro-manage is not entirely clear. We don’t really know. Evidence is largely anecdotal. Scant empirical evidence exists. We have not studied this much nor have many others but this is our assumption. We assume parents are worrying and coddling.  They do too much of their kids’ homework and laundry and don’t take their smart phones or iTunes passwords away enough. (Although we can’t help but mention you aren’t monitoring those phones enough either. Do you know your kid has been sexting? sexting!)

We should also add that even if parents are focusing a lot on their kids (even if it's on the wrong things), it might not be their fault. Not totally. It’s not clear if or to what extent parents should be held responsible. Other factors or aspect of modern life might also be blamed for the current parenting atmosphere. Also in a very very minimal manner we experts might have inadvertently and we stress this is only hypothetical at this point, we might have some very minimal responsibility here.

We have not assessed forces outside parents’ control that might impact how much time, money or emotional fortitude parents spend on their children today (with the possible exception of cyber bullying and here we know all the dangers lurking online that you can’t control totally but have you checked your daughter’s Instagram today?) No, instead of studying or even discussing these other developments in the world, it is much easier to scold parents for being too involved and micromanaging their children’s lives – and at the same time, providing too much leniency in a number of critical areas (too much sugar, video games, not enough exercise or time outs), the world is a dangerous place!

To our great disappointment,  we have not been as focused on the larger, socio-cultural aspects of modern life, such as the economy, the educational environment, the workplace, upheavals in marriage, family life, entertainment, neighborhood, mobile society, new media, social media, advances in science and pediatric medicine, what we know about epigenetics, namely that you are also responsible for your great-grandchildren’s health – yes, these type of factors - that might make parents spend more time, money or anxiety on their children.

Whenever I encounter a hint that parents micromanage or hover, then I would like some evidence, and also a broader view of forces, many of them outside of parental control, that set them up to be over-vigilant, lenient in some areas (too much tv, too much sugar, etc.). That discussion is woefully absent from parenting books today. Heck, articles about parenting books. Any parenting articles for that matter. So let’s start having it.

True, there are things parents can do to ease up, to let their kids become more independent, responsible, possibly even kinder and more curious and creative. I could regale you with examples of hovering from my own life, including my own behavior but that is too easy and doesn't get us any closer to figuring out why this is happening. Instead, let’s have a larger discussion, placing hyper parenting in context of widespread societal and cultural changes.

What kind of external, non-parental forces might be at play? I’m not entirely sure. Life is a big, complicated, information-rich, inter-connected place. As a social psychologist, I’m certain there are forces outside a mother’s control that require her to spend a significant amount of  time and attention attending to childcare matters. 

For instance, paperwork. 

Say forms that a parent needs to complete for school. 

Medical/health/immunization forms
Field trip permission forms
Tell-me-something about-your kid forms
After-school-extracurricular-forms
My-child-can-go-home-with-somebody-else forms
Picture-day-forms
No-I-don’t-want-a-school-photo-form
My-kid-and–I-read-The-honor-code-together-and-discussed-it-forms
The-emergency-contact-forms
The-snow-day-contact-forms
I-swear-my-child-has-completed-all-the-day’s-homework forms
My-child-has-read-for-20-minutes-forms
I-read-to-my-child-for-twenty-minutes-forms
My-child-has-all-her-school-supplies forms
I-looked-at-my-kid's-test-forms
Now-I-know-my-kid-missed-a-homework-assignment-forms
Now-I-know-my-kid-got-a-bad-grade-forms
I-don’t-want-my-child’s photo-on-the-website-forms
My-kid-can-watch-a-PG-13-movie-and-I-won't-sue-you-form
I-read- the-importance-of-community service/diversity/ecology-forms
I-release-the-school from-all-liability-don’t-sue-us-forms
I’ve-read-the-course-requirements-and-classroom behavior-forms
I’ve-signed-off-on-next-year’s courses-forms
I’ve-read-all-the-athletic-participation-rules-forms
I’ve-read-all-the-school-musical-rules-forms
I’ve-read-all-the-above-forms-and-still-won't-sue-forms

Not to mention the forms you don’t have to sign and return. Not to imply these are not important. But they take time. 

Granted, it’s a small piece of the puzzle but part of a parent’s daily life. Every parent whose child goes to school knows how forms can turn a reasonable mom or dad into a hyper parent (i.e. spending too much attention on a child). These small necessities add up, requiring chunks of a mother's waking hours.

I'll give you another example.

Here’s another parenting experience strongly recommended by experts that necessitates a mother spend considerable time, attention and logistical planning on her child. About a year’s worth per child. Yep. Breastfeeding for a year. That’s a commitment, even under the best workplace, lactation-friendly, compliant baby environment. I welcome other examples. I’m sure you all have some.

So tell me, who is to blame for parents spending lots of time and attention on children?

*Nor is it known how parents feel about the parenting advice industry. I've never been able to find any surveys on the matter. Nobody has bothered asking parents what they think.

UPDATE: Thanks, everyone for emailing me examples of hyper parenting! I should write another post. Especially considering WebMD just compiled a seminal slideshow, 7 Signs You Might Be a Helicopter Parent. Enjoy.